know the face huge mustache Every Sigma Male meme, every gym motivation page, every “what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger” caption somehow ended up in existence. The dead philosopher turned into a personality type on the Internet.
But here’s the thing. That version of Friedrich Nietzsche and the real Friedrich Nietzsche are two completely different people. And the distance between them is one of the most fascinating and quietly sad stories in the history of human thought.
Whether his philosophy was right or wrong is not disputed. That conversation exists and it’s a long one. This is just an introduction to the real man and what he actually believed. Because before you quote him or dismiss him or put him on your wall, you should probably know who he is and what he’s really saying.
little priest
Nietzsche grew up surrounded by deeply religious women. His father was a Lutheran pastor who died when Friedrich was only four years old. The family he grew up in was quiet, pious and polite.
And so he was.
He was so meek and soft-spoken as a boy that his classmates gave him a nickname. The little priest. Not as a compliment. As a tease. Wherever he rented rooms throughout Europe, he was adored by his landlords. Not as a dangerous radical. Just like a sweet, considerate tenant who pays on time, doesn’t cause any problems, and plays the piano beautifully.
That’s the same man behind the most famous gym caption in history.
He tried to join the army and couldn’t because the sight of blood made him physically ill. By his thirties his body was collapsing beneath him. The migraines are so intense that they make him vomit about two hundred days a year. His eyesight is deteriorating to near blindness. He spent nearly a decade traveling across Europe, writing his most explosive works in rented rooms, mostly surviving on oatmeal and tea, completely alone.
The man who preached the will to power did so from a position of almost total physical destruction.
Which he actually believed
This is where most people find Nietzsche completely wrong. They see the quotes, the tough guy imagery, the “God is dead” line, and they assume he was some kind of angry nihilist who tells everyone nothing matters.
Almost the opposite of what he was saying.
When Nietzsche said God is dead, he wasn’t celebrating. He warned. He looked at modern Europe and saw a civilization that had quietly ceased to believe in God but had not replaced that premise with anything else. There are no new values. No new money. Just slow down to nothingness. He thought it was really dangerous and he was worried about it.
His answer was the Übermensch. Usually translated as Superman but not the cape and tights version. Nietzsche refers to a person who creates their own values rather than inheriting religion, tradition, or what everyone around them believes. Anyone who looks at the question of how to live and answers it himself without borrowing someone else’s answer.
Not an unethical person. A person who takes responsibility for their own ethics rather than outsourcing.
And then there are the ideas that make people most uncomfortable. Master and slave morality. Nietzsche turned the other cheek on traditional values, humility, meekness, patience, and argued that these were not inherently good values. They were values invented by powerless people to make powerlessness feel noble. He called it slave morality. The powerful, he argued, were always governed by an entirely different code. Not good vs. evil but strong vs. weak, creative vs. mediocre, life-affirming vs. life-denying.
He didn’t say to be cruel. He asked where does your morality actually come from? Did you choose it or did you just hand it over and ask it not to be questioned.
This question is still really uncomfortable. Perhaps that’s why it’s still quoted on gym walls stripped of all its original meaning.
He is not writing what he was. He was writing what he needed.
Historian Will Durant was the name of what Nietzsche was doing with all this. He called it compensation. Nietzsche didn’t write about power and power and the Ubermensch because he embodied these things. He wrote about them because he didn’t have them and needed a philosophy that could help him live anyway.
His writing was not a mirror of his life. This is the medicine he prescribed for himself when he was ill.
He preached Amr Fati. Love your destiny. Accept and fully embrace everything that life throws at you. One of his most powerful ideas.
Then Lou Salome happened.
She was the woman he loved deeply and completely. He proposed. He refused. And Friedrich Nietzsche, the man who told the world to love its fate, did not love its fate. He spirals badly. broke down The depression that followed was dark and severe and nothing about it resembled the philosophy he wrote about.
He was not a hypocrite. He was human. He was writing towards something he had not yet reached and perhaps not fully done. The vision was the destination he was trying to walk towards, not the place he was already standing.
Crack the mask
In Turin in January 1889, Nietzsche saw a horse mauled in the street. He rushed at it, threw his arms around the animal and collapsed completely. Everything that had gathered inside him was gone in that moment.
He never recovered.
He spent the last eleven years of his life in mental turmoil. He sometimes signed his letters as Dionysus. Sometimes as a crucified one. He had no memory of what he had written days or decades before.
And then her sister made everything worse.
Elisabeth Forster-Nietzsche took control of his unpublished work and edited it with her own agenda. selectively. deliberately He shaped his notes to conform to the nationalism and ideas that he argued loudly and repeatedly against throughout his career. A man who clearly abhorred anti-Semitism and was packaged to the world directly as something close to a Nazi intellectual.
A profound betrayal of everything he actually stood for. And he left, he couldn’t fight it.
The Ending He Got
He died in 1900 after spending a decade mentally absent from his own life. He had almost no readers before the breakup. His books sold very poorly. The audience he desperately wanted never came while he was alive and able to know it.
He calls himself Dynamite. He believed that his ideas would divide history into two parts. But he died thinking he was a complete failure. no love He could not retain any recognition. no health At the end of life, only silence passed, screaming like an empty room.
The Sigma Male meme was built on a man who cried over a horse and spent his last years not knowing his own name.
A gentle, sickly, heartbroken, brilliant man, writing furiously towards a version of himself he never quite became. Asking the hardest questions about morality, money and what people are really capable of — while trying to live the answers personally.
Whether he was right or wrong will sit with you.
But now at least you know who was actually asking.
–
This post was Previously published at medium.com.
Love affair? We promise a better stay with your inbox.
Subscribe to get dating and relationship advice 3x weekly.
do you know We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: John Tyson on Unsplash
