I once spent three weeks chatting with someone online before realizing I couldn’t tell if they were a man or a woman.
We discussed music, food, terrible bosses and childhood embarrassments. We’ve somehow solved world hunger twice, yet the single question that every curious person secretly wonders about remains unanswered.
Who exactly was I talking to?
Naturally, my detective instincts kicked in.
I analyzed the punctuation as if it were proof. I counted the emojis. I tested the response time. I wonder what the word even uses “brother” Twice in one afternoon there was a signal or simply emotional weather.
I was wrong.
As it turns out, trying to identify someone’s gender through a chat message is a bit like trying to identify a bird from its sneeze. Sometimes you are lucky. Most of the time you are confidently wrong.
Still, after years of chatting with people online, I’ve noticed a few interesting patterns. not the rule Not a guarantee. A few observations that sometimes make you think, Hmm… maybe?
And sometimes you look spectacularly stupid.
The emoji rabbit hole
A friend told me, “If they use a lot of emojis, it’s probably a woman.”
Five minutes later another friend, a six-foot-long bearded mechanic cool enough to deserve his own postal code, sent me a funny joke with six emojis.
There went that theory.
People use emoji differently. Some decorate each sentence as if they were icing cupcakes. Others treat the smiley face as if it costs money. Neither says much about gender.
It mostly says whether one enjoys mental punctuation.
One-word answer
“Okay.”
“Cold.”
“Beautiful.”
My brain immediately translates these:
“It must be a guy.”
Then my sister answers exactly the same because she’s busy carrying groceries, answering texts, and keeping the dog from eating her slippers.
Sometimes a short answer simply means…
…life just happened.
Detailed Masters
People often claim that boys text one way and girls text another. The reality is not nearly so simple.
Some people might describe buying bread as if they were narrating an award-winning documentary.
“I went to the supermarket because we didn’t have sour cream. Then I met the sweetest old gentleman who insisted that tomatoes should never be refrigerated…”
Others wrote:
“Bought bread.”
No style belongs exclusively to one gender. You can’t judge by message length alone.
That said, people often develop personal writing habits. Some people just enjoy telling stories.
Others communicate like encrypted military radio operators.
They don’t match the stereotypes
This is where most people go wrong.
Does anyone like cars? To be a man.
Does anyone love baking? Must be a girl.
except…
I know women who can rebuild motorcycle engines. I know men who make cakes so beautiful they deserve the light of a museum.
Interests are terrible gender identifiers. Humans are surprisingly unpredictable.
The sooner we stop treating hobbies like personality tests, the less awkward assumptions we’ll make.
Mysterious Vanishing Act
You are having a wonderful conversation.
Then…
the silence
Minutes become hours. The hour will be tomorrow.
Finally they came back with:
“Sorry.”
That’s it.
just…
“Sorry.”
My imagination immediately conjures up fourteen dramatic scenes involving kidnappings, pirate ships and spontaneous alpaca farming.
Reality?
“My phone is dead.”
Online conversations have taught me that invisibility is not a personality trait. It’s usually just adults wearing mud boots.
Their humor doesn’t help you at all
Some jokes seem stereotypically masculine. Others seem stereotypically feminine.
Then along comes someone whose sense of humor is so delightfully deranged that your theories immediately fall apart.
A friend sends healthy cat memes. The next minute they’re cracking jokes that would make a stand-up comedian cringe.
Humor has no dress code.
Extremely helpful person
Some people can’t resist solving your problems. You say your chair squeaks.
Suddenly they recommend three lubricants, two screwdrivers, a YouTube tutorial and maybe a structural engineer.
Others simply say,
“That sounds boring.”
None of the responses reveal gender. It publishes operating systems. Some people solve problems. Others are sympathetic.
Rare Unicorn somehow manages both.
Typing Style Olympics
Some write like this…
a sentence
Another sentence.
Nice spacing.
Easy to read.
Others send a single paragraph so huge that scrolling through it feels like descending into an abandoned mine.
I have met men and women in both camps.
The only universal truth is that no one enjoys the victim for the time the punishment ends.
The Laugh Test
“Haha.”
“Lol.”
“Lamao.”
People smile differently online. Some sprinkle smiles everywhere like parmesan cheese.
Others save “LOL” for truly hilarious moments. The funniest people, I’ve discovered, don’t rely on laughter.
They just say something so absurdly specific that you can’t help but laugh.
No plot twists coming
Finally, curiosity got the better of me.
I casually asked the person I was chatting with,
“So… random question… are you a boy or a girl?”
Answer them?
“Me neither. I’m your aunt.”
Turns out it really was my aunt.
He created a new account after forgetting the old one’s password and somehow didn’t mention who he was.
To this day, family dinners feel a little different.
Mainly because everyone knows I once tried to profile my own aunt based on emoji frequency and response times… when I should recognize the woman who still sends me birthday wishes with fourteen cake emojis every year.
So… can you actually tell?
Sometimes you can make an educated guess.
A shared experience, a casual reference to a partner, a story from childhood, or even someone can refer to themselves can provide clues.
But the guess is just that, guess. The internet is amazingly weird.
People borrow expressions from friends. They take slander from the gaming community. They pick up habits from co-workers, siblings, favorite creators or complete strangers.
Some women type like a hungry grandfather. Some men text like panicked nannies.
Some people deliberately keep everyone guessing because they enjoy watching the rest of us create intelligence boards connected by imaginary red strings.
And honestly?
Good for them.
The older I get, the more interested I am in guessing someone’s gender, and the more interested I am in whether they’re kind, funny, curious, and capable of appreciating an exceptionally creepy pun.
These things make conversation memorable. Gender rarely does.
So, the next time you’re tempted to play Internet Sherlock, remember this:
The person behind the curtain may surprise you. The quiet gamer can be a grandmother. A man who constantly talks about football can knit a scarf at half time.
Or they could be your aunt.
Either way, don’t assume. People refuse to fit neatly into categories.
If you’re really curious, there’s an incredibly effective method that’s also somewhat dramatic.
ask Naturally, when the conversation reaches that point.
Something as simple as, “Anyway, I’m wondering, how do you identify?”
Most people wouldn’t mind.
And if they choose not to answer, that’s fine too. Respect does not require a profile picture.
Additionally, real connection doesn’t depend on getting someone’s gender right, it depends on seeing the person behind the keyboard.
Sometimes the best conversations happen when we stop trying to figure out who someone is and simply enjoy getting to know them.
Thank you for taking the time to read. It means a lot.
Ansel
–
This post was Previously published at medium.com.
Love affair? We promise a better stay with your inbox.
Subscribe to get dating and relationship advice 3x weekly.
do you know We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Brooke Cagle at Unsplash
